Best Hotels in Amherst, NY

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Katerina Kore

Updated: 08 January 2024 · 3 min

Nestled in the picturesque state of New York, Amherst stands out as a serene suburb of Buffalo, offering a unique blend of cultural richness, scenic beauty, and academic excellence with the presence of the University at Buffalo. This charming area is not only known for its tranquil neighborhoods and vibrant collegiate atmosphere but also for its variety of accommodations that cater to every type of traveler. The selection of hotels in Amherst promises to enhance your visit, whether you're in town for business, leisure, or educational pursuits, ensuring a comfortable and memorable stay.

Finding the right hotel in Amherst can elevate your experience from good to extraordinary. With options ranging from luxurious full-service hotels to cozy, budget-friendly inns, there's a place for every preference and price point. Many of these establishments provide amenities such as complimentary breakfasts, fitness centers, and easy access to key local attractions, including shopping centers, parks, and dining options, enriching your exploration of this diverse locality.

Moreover, staying in an Amherst hotel situates you conveniently close to Niagara Falls, one of the natural wonders of the world, and the bustling city of Buffalo, exposing you to an array of experiences from breathtaking nature to urban exploration. Recommendations and insights from locals and fellow travelers alike suggest that Amherst hotels offer the perfect home base for discovering the broader region's attractions. These accommodations not only promise comfort and convenience but also provide an intimate glimpse into the warm hospitality characteristic of upstate New York, making your stay in Amherst an unforgettable part of your journey.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 6

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Charming Farmhouse Home In Amherst
2. Amherst Inn
3. Inn On Boltwood
4. Long Mountain Suite
5. University Lodge
6. Hotel Umass

Luxury Stays at Amherst N Y Hotels

Check Availability

Amherst
Jan 19, 2026 - Jan 20, 2026

Charming Farmhouse Home In Amherst

+ 10 photos
For a more intimate and quaint stay in Amherst, the Charming Farmhouse Home stands as a testament to rustic elegance and comfort. This unique accommodation offers a departure from traditional hotel stays, providing guests with a cozy, home-away-from-home atmosphere in a beautifully maintained farmhouse setting. Each room is decorated with a blend of antique and contemporary furnishings, creating a warm and inviting environment. The surrounding gardens and outdoor spaces offer serene spots for relaxation and enjoying the tranquil Amherst countryside. This farmhouse is perfect for those seeking a peaceful retreat with a personal touch, making it a distinctive option among Amherst N Y hotels for travelers looking for charm and character.
Address: 392 West Street

Luxury Stays at Amherst N Y Hotels

Amherst Inn

8.9

Good

(228 Reviews)

+ 95 photos
The Amherst Inn emerges as a beacon of luxury, offering guests an unforgettable experience with its beautifully designed interiors and impeccable service. Each room is a testament to elegance, featuring fine linens, spacious en-suite bathrooms, and modern amenities that ensure comfort at every turn. The hotel prides itself on its attention to detail, from the gourmet breakfast served each morning to the serene garden spaces that invite relaxation. Guests can enjoy the convenience of being located near Amherst's top attractions while reveling in the peacefulness offered by the hotel's exclusive environment. The Amherst Inn is not just a place to stay; it's a destination that offers a taste of the finer things in life, making it a premier choice among Amherst N Y hotels for those who seek luxury and tranquility.
Address: 257 Main Street
Rating: Good 8.9 (228 Reviews)
Rooms: 7
Price: From 185$

Inn On Boltwood

8.7

Good

(80 Reviews)

+ 56 photos
Located in the heart of Amherst, the Inn On Boltwood stands as a pillar of charm and sophistication. This historic hotel seamlessly integrates classic New England elegance with modern amenities, creating a luxurious yet cozy atmosphere. Guests can choose from a variety of beautifully appointed rooms, each offering unique views of the surrounding town and countryside. The on-site restaurant, renowned for its farm-to-table cuisine, provides an exceptional dining experience that highlights the best of local flavors. The Inn On Boltwood is more than just a place to stay; it's an integral part of the Amherst experience, inviting guests to immerse themselves in the local culture and history while enjoying upscale accommodations.
Address: 30 Boltwood Ave
Rating: Good 8.7 (80 Reviews)
Rooms: 22
Price: From 179$

Long Mountain Suite

+ 12 photos
For those seeking privacy and unrivaled views in Amherst, the Long Mountain Suite offers an exclusive getaway nestled in the scenic landscapes of Amherst. This boutique hotel provides a unique blend of modern luxury and natural beauty, with each suite boasting panoramic views of the mountains and lush surroundings. The sophisticated interiors are designed for comfort and style, from the plush bedding to the spa-like bathrooms. Guests can enjoy the tranquility of the location while benefiting from high-end amenities and personalized service. The Long Mountain Suite is a jewel among Amherst N Y hotels, offering a sanctuary for relaxation and rejuvenation.
Address: 1070 Bay Road

University Lodge

7.7

Good

(117 Reviews)

+ 8 photos
Nestled in the vibrant heart of Amherst, the University Lodge offers a refined experience for travelers. Its proximity to cultural landmarks and the University at Buffalo makes it an ideal choice for visitors who want to immerse themselves in the local scene while enjoying upscale accommodations. The lodge features modern rooms with sleek decor, premium bedding, and state-of-the-art technology, catering to the needs of both leisure and business travelers. Additional amenities include a fully equipped fitness center and exclusive lounge areas, ensuring guests have everything they need for a comfortable stay. The University Lodge stands out as a sophisticated haven, embodying the essence of luxury in Amherst N Y hotels.
Address: 345 North Pleasant Street
Rating: Good 7.7 (117 Reviews)
Rooms: 20
Price: From 60$

Hotel Umass

8.0

Good

(97 Reviews)

+ 29 photos
Hotel Umass rightfully earns its place among the top luxury Amherst hotels, providing a seamless blend of convenience and elegance. Situated within the University of Massachusetts campus, it's an ideal lodging for those visiting for academic reasons or exploring the area. The hotel boasts contemporary rooms adorned with plush furnishings, artwork, and amenities that cater to every comfort. Guests can take advantage of the on-site dining options, which serve exquisite dishes crafted by expert chefs. With its prime location and commitment to excellence, Hotel Umass elevates the standard for luxury stays, offering an experience that is both sophisticated and uniquely Amherst.
Address: 1 Campus Center Way
Rating: Good 8.0 (97 Reviews)
Rooms: 116
Price: From 140$