Top Hotels in Buffalo for Your Western Adventure

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Katerina Kore

Updated: 15 January 2024 · 2 min

Nestled at the foothills of the Bighorn Mountains, Buffalo is a captivating blend of Western history and natural beauty, making it a must-visit destination for travelers seeking an authentic American West experience. This charming town does not only serve as a gateway to outdoor adventures but also houses a variety of accommodations that cater to every traveler's needs. From rustic lodges that echo the spirit of the frontier to modern hotels offering all the conveniences of the 21st century, finding the perfect stay in Buffalo is an adventure in itself.

The choice of hotels in Buffalo is as diverse as the landscapes that surround the town. For those looking to immerse themselves in the rich history and culture of the region, staying in a hotel that embodies the antique charm of the Old West is a must. Meanwhile, travelers prioritizing comfort and modern amenities can find several options that provide luxurious accommodations without sacrificing the local flavor. This fusion of old and new ensures that every visitor can find a hotel that matches their preferences and enhances their experience of Buffalo .

Selecting the right hotel can significantly impact your journey, turning a simple visit into an unforgettable adventure. Thus, exploring the variety of Buffalo hotels is more than just about finding a place to stay; it's about discovering a home base that complements your travel goals. Whether you're in town to explore the majestic Bighorn National Forest, delve into the rich tapestry of the American West at the local museums, or simply soak in the serene beauty of Wyoming, the right hotel awaits to complete your experience. Read on as we delve into recommendations and insights to guide you in choosing the ideal accommodation in Buffalo .
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 3

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Mansion House Motel
2. Z Bar Motel
3. Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites Downtown

Historic Charm in Buffalo Wyoming Hotels

Check Availability

Buffalo
Mar 23, 2026 - Mar 24, 2026

Mansion House Motel

8.0

Good

(86 Reviews)

+ 62 photos
The Mansion House Motel, a jewel in Buffalo's lodging scene, embodies the historical essence of Wyoming. With its vintage facade and warm, inviting interior, the motel provides a nostalgic stay without foregoing the modern luxuries travelers expect. Each room is carefully decorated to mirror the historical elegance of the era, complemented by the kind of personalized service that harks back to a bygone era of hospitality. The motel's location is perfect for those eager to explore Buffalo's rich history, placing guests near local landmarks and attractions. The Mansion House Motel's charm lies in its ability to merge the past with the present, offering a tranquil, comfortable, and genuinely historical lodging option. This establishment proves that embracing heritage can create a distinctive and enriching hospitality experience.
Address: 313 North Main Street
Rating: Good 8.0 (86 Reviews)
Rooms: 10
Price: From 87$

Historic Charm in Buffalo Wyoming Hotels

Z Bar Motel

9.1

Good

(590 Reviews)

+ 112 photos
The Z Bar Motel stands as a testament to Buffalo's vibrant history, offering guests a cozy retreat amidst rustic surroundings. Each cabin at the Z Bar Motel exudes a distinct Old West vibe, complete with modern amenities to ensure a comfortable stay. Guests are treated to a unique blend of historical charm and contemporary conveniences, making it an ideal choice for those seeking both authenticity and comfort. Surrounded by scenic views and with a history that's palpable in its walls, the motel offers a serene getaway with a strong sense of place. The meticulously maintained grounds and friendly staff add to the charm, providing an inviting atmosphere for guests. It's an experience that transcends the ordinary hotel stay, inviting guests to step back in time while enjoying all the comforts of the present.
Address: 626 Fort Street
Rating: Good 9.1 (590 Reviews)
Rooms: 25
Price: From 75$

Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites Downtown

8.5

Good

(24 Reviews)

+ 73 photos
The Historic Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites offer an unparalleled opportunity to immerse oneself in Buffalo's storied past. Occupying a restored building with a history as rich and vibrant as the town itself, the suites offer guests a chance to live in the elegance and grandeur of early Buffalo. Each suite has been thoughtfully designed to reflect the period's luxury while incorporating modern conveniences for a truly comfortable stay. The attention to detail in the restoration and decoration efforts ensures that each guest's experience is as authentic as it is luxurious. Located in the very heart of downtown, it’s an ideal base for exploring the historical and cultural sites of Buffalo. The Capitol Hotel Vacation Suites stand as a beacon of Buffalo's heritage, offering a lodging experience that is both deeply historical and delightfully luxurious.
Address: 70 South Main Street
Rating: Good 8.5 (24 Reviews)
Price: From 168$